Here’s a quick breakdown:
- Cold Emails:
- Open rates: 50-80%
- Reply rates: 5-15%
- Cost per lead: As low as $3.63
- Scales easily (500-1,000 contacts/day)
- LinkedIn DMs:
- Reply rates: Up to 39%
- Higher engagement and relationship-building
- Limited scalability (100-150 messages/day)
- Requires more time and higher costs
Quick Comparison
Metric | Cold Email | LinkedIn DMs |
Open Rate | 50-80% | Nearly 100% |
Reply Rate | 5-15% | 15-39% |
Meeting Conversion | 2-5% | 5-15% |
Monthly Tool Costs | $30-100 | $75-249 |
Daily Time Investment | 30-45 mins | 1-2 hours |
Scalability Limit | 500-1,000/day | 100-150/day |
Choose cold emails for cost-effective, large-scale outreach. Use LinkedIn DMs for personal engagement with high-value prospects. Combining both often yields the best results.
How to Measure Success: Key ROI Metrics
Response and Conversion Rates
Cold emails often see open rates ranging from 50-80% and reply rates between 5-15%. On the other hand, LinkedIn DMs can achieve reply rates as high as 39% [1]. Key metrics to watch include initial engagement (opens or views), responses, new connections, and ultimate conversions, such as booked meetings or sales-qualified leads.
Cost and Time Per Lead
Tracking response rates is important, but understanding the cost and time involved per lead is just as crucial. Cold email campaigns can be highly affordable, with some generating leads for as little as $3.63 [2]. LinkedIn DMs, however, come with higher upfront costs, including premium subscriptions and InMail credit expenses.
Time commitment also varies. Cold emails benefit from automation, making it easier to scale efforts. LinkedIn DMs, while more personalized, demand more manual effort but often lead to stronger connections.
Scalability and Long-Term Results
Cold emails are easier to scale with fewer restrictions, though maintaining quality requires careful attention to deliverability. LinkedIn DMs, while more relationship-focused, face challenges like connection limits and InMail credit caps. This makes them less scalable but effective for nurturing personal relationships.
To maximize results, monitor these metrics consistently and tweak your approach based on performance data. Over time, response rates tend to improve as you refine your methods and build a solid sender reputation.
Next, let’s dive deeper into cold emails and explore when they deliver the best ROI.
Cold Email Results Breakdown
Cold Email Performance: Opens, Replies, and Sales
Cold email campaigns typically see open rates between 50-80% and reply rates of 5-15%, with the best campaigns performing even higher thanks to precise targeting and personalized messaging. Among those replies, up to 10% can lead to meetings or sales in top-performing campaigns.
Here's how the metrics stack up:
Metric | Average Performance | Top Performance |
Open Rate | 50-80% | Up to 85% |
Reply Rate | 5-15% | Up to 45% |
Meeting Conversion | 2-5% | Up to 10% |
Budget and Time Investment for Cold Email Campaigns
Cold email campaigns are efficient, especially when automated. Here's a breakdown of the time and budget typically required:
Time Investment:
- Setup and tool configuration: 4–8 hours
- Content creation and templates: 2–4 hours
- Daily management and tweaks: 30–60 minutes
Cost Breakdown:
Expense Category | Monthly Cost Range |
Email Tools (Automation & Warm-up) | $45–200 |
List Building Tools | $50–200 |
Content Creation | $100–500 |
Ideal Scenarios for Cold Email
Cold email works best in B2B contexts where efficiency and scale are key priorities [1]. It’s especially effective for:
- Launching products to a large audience
- Offering services tailored to specific industries
- Generating leads for high-value B2B solutions
Cold Email VS Linkedin Message: What is Better For B2B Prospecting?
LinkedIn DM Results Breakdown
When it comes to ROI, LinkedIn DMs stand out as a more personal - though time-consuming - alternative to cold emails. They shine in situations where building relationships is a priority.
LinkedIn DM Metrics: Accepts, Replies, and Sales
LinkedIn direct messages often outperform cold emails in engagement. For instance, reply rates for LinkedIn DMs can reach up to 39%, compared to the 5-15% typical of cold emails [1].
Metric | Average Performance | Top Performance |
Connection Accept Rate | 19-25% | Up to 40% |
Reply Rate | 15-25% | Up to 39% |
Meeting Conversion | 5-10% | Up to 15% |
Budget and Time Commitment for LinkedIn DMs
Unlike cold emails, LinkedIn DMs demand both premium tools and tailored outreach. This adds to costs and requires a greater time investment.
Financial Costs:
Expense Category | Monthly Cost |
LinkedIn Tools | $75-249 |
Content Creation | $200-600 |
Profile Optimization | $100-300 (one-time) |
Time Commitment:
- Daily outreach and personalization: 1-2 hours
- Campaign monitoring: 2-3 hours per week
Best Use Cases for LinkedIn DMs
LinkedIn DMs are particularly effective in B2B scenarios where personal engagement is key. Examples include:
- Account-based marketing initiatives
- Reaching out to executives
- Services with longer sales cycles, like consulting
- Technology and SaaS companies targeting decision-makers
Using LinkedIn Sales Navigator to find active users and ideal prospects boosts effectiveness [1]. The platform rewards genuine interactions, so manual engagement plays a crucial role in achieving results.
With these metrics and insights, we can now directly compare LinkedIn DMs and cold emails to see which delivers better ROI for your specific goals.
Direct Comparison: Cold Email vs LinkedIn DMs
Performance Data Table
Here's a breakdown of key metrics for both outreach methods:
Metric | Cold Email | LinkedIn DMs |
Open Rate | 50-80% | Nearly 100% |
Reply Rate | 5-15% | 15-39% |
Meeting Conversion | 2-5% | 5-15% |
Monthly Tool Costs | $30-100 | $75-249 |
Daily Time Investment | 30-45 mins | 1-2 hours |
Scalability Limit | 500-1,000 contacts/day | 100-150 personalized messages/day |
Pros and Cons List
Benefits of Cold Email:
- Scales easily for large outreach campaigns
- Affordable, with lower tool costs
- Supports automation for efficiency
- No restrictions on the number of connections
- Simplifies testing with A/B options
Drawbacks of Cold Email:
- Lower response rates compared to LinkedIn
- Risk of emails landing in spam folders
- Feels less personal to recipients
Benefits of LinkedIn DMs:
- Higher engagement rates
- Access to detailed profiles of prospects
- Leverages LinkedIn's professional network
- Builds stronger relationships with prospects
- Offers advanced targeting features
Drawbacks of LinkedIn DMs:
- Limited by connection caps
- More expensive tools
- Requires significant time for personalization
- Daily outreach limits
- Potential risk of account restrictions
Which Method Fits Your Goals?
Go with Cold Email if:
- You need to reach a large audience, have a limited budget, or are working with shorter sales cycles and broader markets.
Opt for LinkedIn DMs if:
- Your focus is on account-based marketing, building relationships, targeting senior executives, or selling high-ticket products.
Combining both methods often works best. For example, start with LinkedIn DMs to connect with high-value prospects, then use cold emails to scale your follow-up efforts. This approach balances personalization with efficiency [1][3].
No matter the method, fine-tuning your strategy is essential for maximizing your results. Up next, we'll dive into actionable tips for success on both platforms.
How to Get Better Results on Both Platforms
Cold Email Success Tips
To run a successful cold email campaign, focus on personalization and ensuring your emails actually reach inboxes. Start by warming up your email account to build a strong sender reputation and avoid landing in spam.
Here are three areas to prioritize:
Building a Targeted ListUse tools like Apollo.io or Hunter.io to create a focused list of prospects. Filter by key factors like company size, industry, and job title to ensure you're emailing the right decision-makers.
Crafting the Right MessageKeep your email short and to the point. Include these elements:
- Personalized subject lines that mention the recipient's company or recent accomplishments
- An opening that highlights a specific challenge they face and how you can help
- A single, clear call-to-action
- A professional signature that includes some form of credibility, like an award or client success
Technical SetupSet up your email system properly. Authenticate your domain (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), stick to a consistent sending schedule, and use A/B testing to refine your approach for better results.
LinkedIn DM Success Tips
Start by optimizing your LinkedIn profile. A professional headshot can boost profile views by 14x [1], making a great first impression. After that, focus on quality over quantity when it comes to outreach.
Message Framework That WorksKeep your messages short - ideally under 400 characters. Personalize your opening by mentioning shared connections or interests. Clearly explain how you can provide value, and end with a specific, actionable next step. Maintain a professional but conversational tone.
Getting the Most Out of Sales NavigatorUse LinkedIn Sales Navigator to take your outreach to the next level:
- Save searches to match your ideal customer profile
- Monitor prospect interactions with your content
- Use activity filters to find prospects who are recently active
- Track job changes and company updates to time your outreach effectively
Using Both Methods Together
For the best results, combine LinkedIn and cold email into a single, coordinated strategy. Start by researching and connecting with prospects on LinkedIn, then follow up with a personalized email referencing your LinkedIn interaction. Alternate between the two platforms depending on how the prospect engages with you.
How to Combine Them Effectively
- Use LinkedIn to research and connect with prospects
- Send follow-up emails that reference your LinkedIn connection
- Switch between LinkedIn and email based on how prospects respond
- Track responses on both platforms to avoid doubling up
Keep your messaging consistent across platforms, but adjust your tone to fit each one. Emails can be more formal and detailed, while LinkedIn messages should feel conversational and focused on networking.
Data shows that combining LinkedIn's strong engagement rates with cold email's scalability creates a well-rounded strategy. By using both platforms, you can build an outreach approach that maximizes engagement and delivers better ROI.
Conclusion: Making Your Final Choice
Key Takeaways
Cold emails are great for reaching a large audience at a lower cost, while LinkedIn DMs shine when it comes to engagement and building relationships. The cost structures differ too: cold emails involve upfront investments in tools but scale well, whereas LinkedIn adds expenses like Sales Navigator, which can impact your return on investment.
Now, let’s look at how to decide which approach works best for your business.
Deciding on the Right Approach
Your decision should depend on your business needs and objectives:
Go with Cold Email if You Need:
- A cost-effective way to reach a large audience
- Full control over automation
- Flexibility in crafting different types of messages
Opt for LinkedIn DMs if You Want:
- Better engagement with your prospects
- Increased visibility within professional networks
- A focus on building stronger relationships
Use Both Methods if:
- Your audience is active on multiple platforms
- You aim for broad market coverage
- Your sales process involves multiple interactions
For many businesses, combining these methods can deliver the best results by leveraging the strengths of both.
Artemis Leads: Your Multichannel Outreach Partner
Not sure how to balance cold emails and LinkedIn DMs? Artemis Leads can help. They offer expert management of multichannel outreach, combining the advantages of both approaches to ensure consistent messaging and maximum reach to your ideal customers.
FAQs
Is it better to cold email or cold LinkedIn message?
Choosing between cold emails and LinkedIn messages depends on your specific B2B goals and available resources. Cold emails often achieve open rates of 50-80% for top performers and are a cost-efficient way to reach a larger audience [1]. They work best when you need to:
- Reach a broad audience without connection limits
- Use automation tools for streamlined outreach
- Stick to a tight budget
On the other hand, LinkedIn DMs, though limited in volume, are great for building connections and fostering engagement [1]. These are ideal when:
- Personal relationships are a priority
- Your audience is highly active on LinkedIn
- You have access to tools like Sales Navigator
While open rates and engagement are useful metrics, conversion rates give a clearer picture of which method works best for your goals.
What is the conversion rate for cold messages on LinkedIn?
Conversion rates depend heavily on how well you target your audience and personalize your messages rather than the platform itself. Cold emails generally convert at 2-5%, making them effective for scaling outreach [2]. LinkedIn DMs tend to see higher engagement but require more effort in crafting personalized messages and often involve premium tools.
Factors that influence conversion rates include:
- How tailored your message is
- The accuracy of your audience targeting
- Your follow-up strategy
- How relevant your content is to the recipient
For the best results, try combining both approaches. Use cold emails for broader campaigns and LinkedIn DMs for high-value leads or when relationship-building is key. This way, you can maximize the strengths of each platform [1].